Delegate Council Bulletin #75
[January 26, 2001]
Agenda: Tuesday, January 30, 2001, 6:30 p.m. Sharp
•Estimated length: 2 hours.
•All ALAA members welcome (only elected representatives may vote).
•Free Pizza/soda served.
1. Adoption of DC Minutes for July 18, 2000 and November 21, 2000 (attached).
2. Criminal Divisions (20 minutes).
2.1. Funding.
2.1.1. City Council budget modification.
2.1.2. Staffing consequences.
2.2. Litigation.
3. Collective Bargaining (30 minutes).
3.1. Results of written member survey (attached).
3.2. Contract amendment to apply parental leave in two-employee LAS households.
1. Internal Business (30 minutes).
4.1. Garnethia Pettiford case. Report on Executive Board investigation of union representation.
4.2. Election of vacant Joint Affirmative Action Committee representatives. Nominations (closed as of January 10, 2001; alternates in parentheses):
•Co-Chair: Shanti Narra (CDD/Manhattan).
•Civil Division: Marie Mombrun (Josephine Flores).
•Criminal Appeals Bureau: (Juan Beritan).
•Juvenile Rights Division: Dod Terry (Michelle Rochester-Rae).
4.3. Part-timer representation. First notice of proposed bylaws amendment to add part-timer representative to the Executive Board (for discussion at subsequent DC).
2. Contributions and Endorsements.
5.1. March 27 Rally to repeal Rockefeller drug laws.
ALAA Delegate Council: July 18, 2000
Legend: Large/Bold=Present; Lowercase=Alternate; Italics=Adopted motion
President
LETWIN
Sec’y-Treasurer
ALBRO
Recording Sec’y
HITCHCOCK
VPCAB/CAP
Fed
BRISKEY
A1: Kaye
VPCDD/Bx
GELTMAN
A1: Bigelow
VPCDD/Bk
ZUSS
A1: Torres
A2: Korotzer
VPCDD/M
GEIDA
A1: Mulligan
VPCDD/Qns
POPPER
A1: Byrne
VPCivil
HOLDER
A1: Valentine
VPJRD
REEVES
A1: Hochberg
VPVol. (CLO)
BING-HAMPSON
A1: Rosa-Rios
A2: Fishman
ACLA*
CODLING
Aff. Action*
VACANT
Health & Safety*
NARRA
Health*
BENJAMIN
Junior*
HUGHES
Lesbian & Gay*
BAHR
Senior*
TORRES
CAB
COHEN
FABIANO
GRAVES
HARPAZ
HOPKIRK
KAYE
LANDAU
LITTLE
PETERS
A1: Taglieri
A2: Blum, P
A3: Sender
Capital Defense
VACANT
CDDBxA
ROGERS
SIM
A1: Rush-Fox
A2: Montoya
A3: Roman
CDDBxB
GARCIA
GURWITCH
A1: Meyerson
A2: Peppito
A3: Warshowksy
CDDBxC
ABBANDANDO
BOMBA
A1: Rudin
A2: Beltre
A3: Kelly
CDDBxD
CHEREBIN
IPPOLITO
A1: Sturman
A2: Albo
A3: Follett
CDDBK1
BAKER
BELL
A1: Costigan
A2: Hughes
A3: Dinjian
CDDBK2
ANGRISANI
ASHWORTH
A1: Korotzer
A2: Pitts
A3: Wright
CDDBK3
RITTER
SHEEHAN
A1: Alzugaray
A2: Flanders
A3: Morris
CDDBK4
PELLEGRINO
CASHMAN
A1: Kurtz
A2: Rudnick
A3: Rahall
CDDBK5
DAVILA
MARTIN
A1: Newman
A2: Pratt
A3: Khashu
CDDM1
DALEY
NEVINS
CDDM2
GROSS
NARRA
CDDM3
BAHR
SCHWARZ
A1: Michaeu
CDDM4
MARON
MULLIGAN
A1: Shapiro
CDDM5
ROBERTS
SOTO
CDDM6
AFFLER
HARRIS
A1: Wright
A2: White
A3: Zablocki
CDDQ1
GRUNDSTEIN
MORRISON
A1: Linneman
A2: Flamholtz
A3: Butchin
CDDQ3
FREDERICK
KNIGHTLY
A1: Haase
A2: Savage
A3: LoPiccolo
CDDQ4
AUSTIN
DIFLUMERI
A1: Byrne
A1: Auguste
A3: Horowitz
CDDSpec Lit
WASSERMAN
CivilAging
BOEHM
A1: Hosannah
A2: Bart
A3: Durham
CivilApp./HRP
BLUM, R
KELLEHER
A1: Goldiner
CivilBronx
FRIEDER
STOLLER
A1: Goetz
CivilBNO
PIZZIMENTI
ROSENBERG
CivilFar Rock
SHORTELL
A1: Dierking
A2: Fielding
CivilHarlem
SACKEY
A1: Shaeffer
A2: Barbosa
Civil–Imm.
FLOYD-MAYER
A1: Navarro
CivilLMNO
DAVOL
A1: Beritan
CivilQueens
FLORES
A1: Mombrun
A2: Kim
A3: Friedheim
CivilSI
MARCUS
A1: Sanchez
A2: McCann
FedApp & SDNY
STATSINGER
FedEDNY
PADDEN
Solotaroff
JRDApp/Sp Lit
EGGER
A1: Rosenbloom
JRDBronx
ROMAN
A1: Abbey
A2: Nevergold
JRDBrooklyn
KARASYK
A1: Koslow
A2: Baum
A3: Nolan
JRDManhattan
LAMB
MARTIN
Pappadopoulos
JRDQueens
BOWLER
SCREEN
A1: Mittler
A2: Chiu
A3: Dandridge
JRDSI
LEE
Parole
LOPEZ
Prisoners Rights
ZELERMYER
Volunteer (CLO)
MARIS
CODLING
A1: Epstein
A2: King
*Nonvoting in this capacity
3. MOMA Strike.
UAW 2110 member Harris Drew reported on the MOMA strike, including the role of management attorney and former LAS labor counsel Bob Batterman.
MOTION (Albro/Geltman): Contribute $500 to MOMA strike hardship fund (passed unanimously with 1 abstention).
4. Outside Counsel for Anthony Chilliest.
MOTION (Zuss/Narra): Approve request from Brooklyn CDD member Anthony Chilliest for up to $1500 reimbursement of outside counsel costs (matchable by LAS) to defend grievance committee investigation following an ADA’s complaint (passed 21-0-1).
5. Transit Checks.
Secretary-Treasurer Albro reported that LAS management is willing to continue TransitCheks (a non-contractual benefit) in the next quarter (7/1/00-9/30/00), provided that it had the necessary $125,000 and ALAA to charge cost against collective bargaining agreement effective October 1, 2000.
MOTION (Albro/Geltman): Charge cost of next quarter (7/1/00-9/30/00) TransitCheks against collective bargaining agreement effective October 1, 2000 (passed 19-1-3).
6. LAS Email Policy Committee.
Discussion of whether ALAA should participate in the LAS email policy committee.
MOTION (Blum/Albro): Authorize ALAA participation in the LAS email policy committee. MOTION (Codling/Popper): Table (passed 12-9).
7. ALAA Finances.
The Secretary-Treasurer distributed to all members present the independent auditor’s statement of ALAA finances for the year ending 12/31/99; statement will be posted to all members via email.
6. Meeting Adjourned. Next meeting: July 18, 2000.
ALAA Delegate Council: November 21, 2000
Legend: Large/Bold=Present; Lowercase=Alternate; Italics=Adopted motion
President
LETWIN
Sec’y-Treasurer
ALBRO
Recording Sec’y
HITCHCOCK
VPCAB/CAP
Fed
BRISKEY
A1: Kaye
VPCDD/Bx
GELTMAN
A1: Bigelow
VPCDD/Bk
ZUSS
A1: Torres
A2: Korotzer
VPCDD/M
GEIDA
A1: Mulligan
VPCDD/Qns
POPPER
A1: Byrne
VPCivil
HOLDER
A1: Valentine
VPJRD
REEVES
A1: Hochberg
VPVol. (CLO)
BING-HAMPSON
A1: Rosa-Rios
A2: Vegas
ACLA*
CODLING
Aff. Action*
VACANT
Health & Safety*
NARRA
Health*
BENJAMIN
Junior*
HUGHES
Lesbian & Gay*
BAHR
Senior*
TORRES
CAB
COHEN
FABIANO
GRAVES
HARPAZ
HOPKIRK
KAYE
LANDAU
LITTLE
PETERS
A1: Taglieri
A2: Blum, P
A3: Sender
Capital Defense
VACANT
CDDBxA
ROGERS
SIM
A1: Rush-Fox
A2: Montoya
A3: Roman
CDDBxB
GARCIA
GURWITCH
A1: Meyerson
A2: Peppito
A3: Warshowksy
CDDBxC
ABBANDANDO
BOMBA
A1: Rudin
A2: Beltre
A3: Kelly
CDDBxD
CHEREBIN
IPPOLITO
A1: Sturman
A2: Albo
A3: Follett
CDDBK1
BAKER
BELL
A1: Costigan
A2: Newton
A3: Dinjian
CDDBK2
ANGRISANI
ASHWORTH
A1: Korotzer
A2: Pitts
A3: Wright
CDDBK3
RITTER
SHEEHAN
A1: Alzugaray
A2: Flanders
A3: Morris
CDDBK4
PELLEGRINO
CASHMAN
A1: Kurtz
A2: Rudnick
A3: Rahall
CDDBK5
DAVILA
MARTIN
A1: Newman
A2: Pratt
A3: Khashu
CDDM1
DALEY
NEVINS
CDDM2
GROSS
NARRA
CDDM3
BAHR
SCHWARZ
A1: Michaeu
CDDM4
MARON
MULLIGAN
A1: Shapiro
CDDM5
ROBERTS
SOTO
CDDM6
AFFLER
HARRIS
A1: Wright
A2: White
A3: Zablocki
CDDQ1
GRUNDSTEIN
MORRISON
A1: Linneman
A2: Flamholtz
A3: Butchin
CDDQ3
FREDERICK
KNIGHTLY
A1: Haase
A2: Savage
A3: LoPiccolo
CDDQ4
AUSTIN
DIFLUMERI
A1: Byrne
A1: Auguste
A3: Horowitz
CDDSpec Lit
WASSERMAN
CivilAging
BOEHM
A1: Hosannah
A2: Bart
A3: Durham
CivilApp./HRP
BLUM, R
KELLEHER
A1: Goldiner
A2: Goldfein
CivilBronx
FRIEDER
STOLLER
A1: Goetz
CivilBNO
PIZZIMENTI
ROSENBERG
CivilFar Rock
SHORTELL
A1: Dierking
A2: Fielding
CivilHarlem
SACKEY
A1: Shaeffer
A2: Barbosa
Civil–Imm.
FLOYD-MAYER
A1: Navarro
CivilLMNO
DAVOL
A1: Beritan
CivilQueens
FLORES
A1: Mombrun
A2: Kim
A3: Friedheim
CivilSI
MARCUS
A1: Sanchez
A2: McCann
FedApp/SDNY
STATSINGER
FedEDNY
PADDEN
Solotaroff
JRDApp/Sp Lit
EGGER
A1: Rosenbloom
JRDBronx
ROMAN
A1: Abbey
A2: Nevergold
JRDBrooklyn
KARASYK
A1: Koslow
A2: Baum
A3: Nolan
JRDManhattan
LAMB
MARTIN
Pappadopoulos
JRDQueens
BOWLER
SCREEN
A1: Mittler
A2: Chiu
A3: Dandridge
JRDSI
LEE
Parole
LOPEZ
Prisoners Rights
ZELERMYER
Volunteer (CLO)
MARIS
CODLING
A1: Epstein
A2: King
A3: Edwards
*Nonvoting in this capacity
8. Political Action.
Albro: Working Families finished fourth among all parties in the November elections. ALAA members played particularly critical role in Liz Krueger candidacy in Upper East Side state senate race.
9. Criminal.
2.1. Funding.
Albro: Our lobbying campaign has convinced many City Council members to support additional LAS funds in upcoming budget modification. Regardless of the outcome, we have strengthened ground for renewed effort in Spring 2001.
2.2. Federal litigation.
Letwin: Depositions are being scheduled for former deputy mayor Randy Levine and former criminal justice coordinator Katie Lapp. Notwithstanding city motion to reargue its partial denial of its motion for summary judgment, court is expected to order Giuliani’s deposition.
2.3. First Department oversight report.
Letwin: New report favorable to all agencies, except CAB; LAS has refuted that criticism as unjustified.
2.4. CDD/Bk traffic cop.
Ashworth: In response to Criminal Court reorganization imposed by DA’s office, CDD/Bk members have withdrawn traffic cops from AP parts.
10. Civil Division.
3.1. Discipline of Garnethia Pettiford (Civil/HRP).
Letwin: Item withdrawn; EB proposal to authorize arbitration of Garnethia Pettiford’s discipline is mooted by severance agreement reached earlier today. EB will resume investigation of questions about Pettiford’s union representation.
3.2. Interim supervisor position.
Holder: Civil-Bx unable to fill long-vacant supervisory position.
MOTION (Holder/Bomba): Authorize 90-day interim supervisor position, pursuant to bylaws (passed: 29-2-2).
11. Juvenile Rights Division.
Letwin: ALAA and management have tentatively settled longstanding division-wide workload grievance; language being drafted.
12. Election of Affirmative Action Representatives.
Letwin: Few additional nominations have been received.
MOTION (Hitchcock/Valentine): Table election of Affirmative Action representatives to next DC (passed: unanimous).
MOTION (Briskey): Nominate Juan Beritan as alternate CAB affirmative action rep. (accepted by nominee).
MOTION (Albro/Blum): Set January 10, 2001 deadline for all additional joint affirmative action rep nominations (passed: unanimous, with 1 abstention).
13. Collective Bargaining.
6.1. Survey.
Albro: Membership surveys are being collected.
6.2. TransitCheks.
Albro: Pursuant to vote at previous DC, TransitCheks will be distributed with first payroll in December 2000.
MOTION (Valentine/Popper): Suspend TransitCheks.
MOTION (Narra/Bomba): Table (passed 26-5-3).
6.3. Pension Plan.
6.3.1. Loans.
Frieder: EB has voted unanimously (with 1 abstention) to approve pension trustees’ proposal to amend plan to permit loans against individual earnings; details forthcoming.
6.3.2. Attorney fees.
Frieder: Due to loan amendment (above), etc., management proposes negotiating, in upcoming contract negotiations, higher annual cap on pension legal fees (which has been unchanged since 1988).
MOTION (Valentine/Goldfein): Ask pension trustees to consider, and report back to DC on, retaining firm other than Proskauer (passed: 17-5-9).
6.4. Health benefits.
Albro: Oxford (staff attorneys) and Cigna (supervisors/exempt) seeks combined $700,000 rate increase in CY01; Oxford and Empire have offered major savings if plans combined (Cigna did not make competitive offer). In response, EB voted unanimously to support combined plans (subject to membership ratification) without compromising benefits or quality of service. Albro and Letwin met with management and agreement was reached to continue current policies (which can be cancelled on 30-day notice) until July 1, pending disruption reports and further bids.
14. Part-Timer Representation [Add-on Item].
Goldiner: Part-timers’ caucus seeks permanent representative on Executive Board.
Letwin: Since bylaws require prior notice at two consecutive meetings, proposal will be noticed for March 2001 DC.
Results of Survey on ALAA Bargaining Goals
December 15, 2000
We received 194 surveys, distributed as follows: Bklyn CDD: 44; CAB (all): 32; Queens CDD: 31; JRD: 28; Civil: 22; Manh. CDD: 14; Bronx CDD: 13; and CLO: 10. Unfortunately, many members did not follow the instructions to pick up to five total items and rate them in priority from 1 to 5. Instead, they either rated more than 5 items, picked and rated 5 items within each of the six categories, gave the same priority number to multiple items, etc. Therefore, rather than exclude those many non-conforming surveys, in the following table we simply tabulated the number of times each item was designated as any choice on any survey.
ITEM |
BK CDD |
QNS CDD |
BX CDD |
MANH CDD |
CAB |
JRD |
CIV |
CLO |
TOTAL |
perm tran checks |
30 |
17 |
10 |
8 |
21 |
18 |
11 |
6 |
121 |
steps > 13, etc. |
17 |
22 |
8 |
8 |
18 |
18 |
10 |
4 |
105 |
higher pensions |
21 |
24 |
5 |
3 |
17 |
13 |
10 |
4 |
97 |
+ comp & vac cash in |
25 |
17 |
5 |
11 |
7 |
6 |
9 |
2 |
82 |
loan forgiven |
27 |
12 |
5 |
6 |
11 |
9 |
9 |
2 |
81 |
workload |
15 |
11 |
2 |
7 |
8 |
14 |
7 |
0 |
64 |
+ dental, vision |
19 |
11 |
4 |
4 |
7 |
10 |
5 |
4 |
64 |
affirm. action |
9 |
6 |
2 |
4 |
14 |
10 |
3 |
4 |
52 |
contin- uity |
11 |
14 |
3 |
4 |
6 |
10 |
3 |
0 |
51 |
retiree benefits |
13 |
10 |
7 |
1 |
7 |
8 |
4 |
1 |
51 |
sickleave to care 4 family |
12 |
11 |
5 |
3 |
8 |
5 |
5 |
1 |
50 |
> P/T options |
7 |
10 |
2 |
4 |
7 |
6 |
10 |
4 |
50 |
+ pers. & relig lv |
12 |
12 |
1 |
4 |
2 |
5 |
5 |
3 |
44 |
Non cdd comp. |
7 |
5 |
0 |
1 |
7 |
10 |
7 |
4 |
41 |
full P/T step inc. |
4 |
7 |
1 |
1 |
10 |
8 |
7 |
1 |
39 |
+ life insurance |
5 |
13 |
2 |
1 |
2 |
5 |
2 |
0 |
30 |
donate leave |
4 |
6 |
1 |
6 |
3 |
2 |
6 |
2 |
30 |
standard fel. cert. |
9 |
10 |
2 |
2 |
0 |
1 |
1 |
0 |
25 |
1 health plan |
9 |
4 |
0 |
0 |
4 |
3 |
3 |
1 |
24 |
no P/T premium pmts |
1 |
3 |
0 |
0 |
6 |
3 |
8 |
2 |
23 |
= P/T wk |
4 |
7 |
1 |
1 |
2 |
2 |
5 |
1 |
23 |
paternity lv 4 both las prnts |
7 |
6 |
2 |
1 |
4 |
1 |
1 |
1 |
23 |
opp. sex partner benefits |
4 |
2 |
0 |
1 |
5 |
2 |
4 |
1 |
19 |
90church bike rm |
2 |
4 |
1 |
1 |
3 |
3 |
2 |
0 |
16 |
rev. bar failure policy |
1 |
4 |
0 |
1 |
3 |
1 |
3 |
1 |
14 |
change ins. co. |
1 |
4 |
0 |
1 |
3 |
1 |
3 |
1 |
14 |
gatekeep. <Rx fees |
4 |
3 |
0 |
0 |
4 |
1 |
2 |
0 |
14 |