Microsoft Word – DCB77
ALAA Delegate Council Bulletin #77
Agenda: Tuesday, May 15, 2001, 6:30 p.m. Sharp
•Estimated length: 1 hour.
•All ALAA members welcome (only elected representatives may vote).
•Free pizza/soda.
1. Adoption of DC Minutes for March 20, 2001 and April 30, 2001 (attached).
2. Political Action (15 minutes).
2.1. City elections.
2.2. Charleston 5 case (see http://www.ilwu.org/index_coalition.htm).
3. Criminal Funding (15 minutes).
3.1. FY02 budget.
3.2. Staffing.
3.3. Litigation.
4. Collective Bargaining (5 minutes)(see attached materials).
5. Internal Business (20 minutes).
5.1. Election of Part-Timer representative to Executive Board. Nominee (closed as of May 8, 2001): Laura Porter (CDD-Manhattan).
5.2. Bylaw Revision Committee. Following UAW response to ALAA bylaws, EB proposes formation of new committee to consider further amendment of bylaws, made up of the Secretary-Treasurer and one representative from each Vice-Presidential constituency.
5.3. UAW audit (materials will be distributed at meeting).
Minutes of ALAA Delegate Council: March 20, 2001
Legend: Black=Present; Gray=Absent; Lowercase=Alternate; Parens=Other ALAA Members
Executive Board
President: LETWIN
Secretary-Treasurer: ALBRO
Recording Secretary: HITCHCOCK
VP–CAB/CAP/Fed: BLUM, P. (Acting), A1: Vacant
VP–CDD/Bx: GELTMAN, A1: Vacant
VP–CDD/Bk: ZUSS, A1: *Torres, A2: *Korotzer
VP–CDD/M: GEIDA, A1: Mulligan
VP–CDD/Qns: POPPER, *A1: Byrne
VP–Civil: HOLDER; A1: Vacant
VP–JRD: HOCHBERG, A1: Vacant
VP–Vol. (CLO): BING-HAMPSON, A1: Rosa-Rios, A2: Vega, A3: Edwards
ACLA: *CODLING
Aff. Action: VACANT
Health & Safety: *KOROTZER
Health: *SMITH
Junior: *HUGHES
Lesbian & Gay: *BAHR
Senior: *TORRES
*Nonvoting in this capacity
Criminal Appeals Bureau (CAB)
COHEN, FABIANO, GRAVES, HARPAZ, HOPKIRK, LANDAU, LITTLE, PETERS, A1: Taglieri, A2: Blum, P, A3: Sender
Capital Defender Division
VACANT
Criminal Defense Division (CDD)-Bronx
BxA: ROGERS, SIM, A1: Rush-Fox, A2: Montoya, A3: Roman
BxB: GARCIA, GURWITCH, A1: Meyerson, A2: Peppito, A3: Warshowksy
BxC: ABBANDANDO, BOMBA, A1: Rudin, A2: Beltre, A3: Kelly
BxD: FOLLETT, IPPOLITO, A1: Sturman, A2: Albo, A3: Follett
Criminal Defense Division (CDD)-Brooklyn
BK1: BAKER, BELL, A1: Costigan, A2: Newton, A3: Dinjian
BK2: ANGRISANI, ASHWORTH, A1: Korotzer, A2: Pitts, A3: Wright
BK3: RITTER, SHEEHAN, A1: Alzugaray, A2: Flanders, A3: Morris
BK4: PELLEGRINO, CASHMAN, A1: Kurtz, A2: Rudnick, A3: Rahall
BK5: DAVILA, PRATT, A1: Newman, A2: Wasserman, R.
Criminal Defense Division (CDD)-Manhattan
M1: DALEY, NEVINS
M2: GROSS, NARRA
M3: BAHR, SCHWARZ, A1: Michaeu
M4: MARON, MULLIGAN, A1: Shapiro
M5: ROBERTS, SOTO
M6: AFFLER, WRIGHT, A1: Zablocki
Spec Lit: WASSERMAN
Criminal Defense Division (CDD)-Queens
Q1: GRUNDSTEIN, MORRISON, A1: Linneman, A2: Vacant
Q3: FREDERICK, KNIGHTLY, A1: Haase, A2: Savage, A3: LoPiccolo
Q4: AUSTIN, DIFLUMERI, A1: Byrne, A1: Auguste, A3: Horowitz
Civil Division
Aging: BOEHM, A1: Hosannah, A2: Bart, A3: Durham
Appeals/HRP: GOLDFEIN, KELLEHER, A1: Goldiner, A2: Bock
Bronx: FRIEDER, STOLLER, A1: Goetz
Brooklyn Neighborhood Office (BNO): PIZZIMENTI, ROSENBERG
Far Rockaway: SHORTELL, A1: Dierking, A2: Fielding
Harlem: SACKEY, A1: Shaeffer, A2: Barbosa
Immigration: FLOYD-MAYER, A1: Navarro
Lower Manhattan Neiborhood Office (LMNO): RHULEN, A1: Bodden
Queens: FLORES, A1: Mombrun, A2: Kim, A3: Friedheim
Staten Island: MARCUS, A1: Sanchez, A2: McCann
(Davol)
Federal Defender Division
Appeals & SDNY: STATSINGER
EDNY: PADDEN, Solotaroff
Juvenile Rights Division (JRD)
Appeals/Spec Lit: EGGER, A1: Rosenbloom
Bronx: ROMAN, A1: Abbey, A2: Nevergold
Brooklyn: KARASYK, A1: Koslow, A2: Baum, A3: Nolan
Manhattan: LAMB, MARTIN, A1: Pappadopoulos
Queens: BOWLER, SCREEN, A1: Mittler, A2: Chiu
Staten Island: LEE
Parole Revocation (PRDU)
LOPEZ
Prisoners Rights Project
ZELERMYER, A1: Beritan
Volunteer Division/(Community Law Office)
MARIS, CODLING, A1: Epstein, *A2: Edwards
NB: Italics=Adopted motion
1. Prior Minutes. MOTION (Torres/Narra): Adopt Delegate Council minutes of January 30, 2001 (passed unanimously).
3. Political Action.
2.1. Drop the Rock. Albro urged members to participate in March 27 ALAA/1199/LAS lobby and protest in Albany to repeal Rockefeller Drug Laws.
2.2. Mayor’s Race. Albro reported on process by which UAW may endorse mayoral candidates. Several members called for early endorsement of candidate Mark Green.
4. Criminal Funding.
3.1. Staffing. Letwin reported ongoing discussion of need to reduce CDD/CAB workload in light of budget cuts. MOTION (Torres/Popper): Hold special DC within next month to discuss CDD/CAB workload/staffing problems, preceded by boro/office level meetings to consider alternative steps (passed: unanimously).
3.2. Litigation. Letwin reported on efforts to schedule Giuliani deposition.
5. Collective Bargaining.
4.1. Bargaining Proposals. Letwin reported on inclusion of additional items in draft contract proposals. MOTION (Albro/Blum): Adopt draft contract proposals submitted by the Executive Board (attached)(passed: unanimously).
6. Internal Business.
5.1. Election to Vacant Executive Board Positions (by secret written ballot) .
5.1.1. Health Benefits: Kathryn Smith (24), Barbara Byrne (18).
5.1.2. Health & Safety: Daniella Korotzer (30), Tom Bomba (12).
5.2. Bylaw Amendment for Part-timer Representation. Final consideration of proposed bylaw amendment to add part-timer representative to the Executive Board. MOTION (Goldiner): Add part-timer representative to the Executive Board (passed: 27-0-4).
ALAA Bargaining Proposals
Adopted March 20, 2001
1. Salaries.
1.1. Increase salaries to achieve ADA comparability; across-the-board increases and additional senior steps.
1.2. Increase comp/vacation buy-back.
2. TransitCheks.
2.1. Permanent contractual benefit.
2.2. Individual option to purchase additional TransitCheks on pretax basis.
3. Pension.
3.1. Increase contributions.
3.2. Fixed contribution schedule.
3.3. More individual investment options.
4. Health Insurance.
4.1. Unified management/staff attorney plans.
4.2. Retiree coverage.
4.3. Opposite-sex domestic partner coverage.
4.4. Increase dental/vision benefits.
4.5. Lower doctor visit and R/X co-pays.
4.6 Contagious disease inoculation.
4.7. Cover birth control pills.
4.8. Cover removable prosthetic devices.
4.9. Permit faxed claim forms.
5. Life Insurance.
5.1. Increase benefit.
5.2. Implement individual option to supplementary group coverage by a date certain.
6. Long-Term Disability.
6.1. Increase benefit.
6.2. Investigate individual option to buy additional coverage on tax-free basis.
7. Loan Forgiveness Fund.
8. Time-Off.
8.1. Paternity benefits for both parents in two-staff attorney households.
8.2. Sick leave to care for ill family members/domestic partners.
8.3. Comp/vacation donations to other staff.
8.4. Personal/religious floating holidays.
8.5. Increase non-CDD personal days.
8.6. Comp. days for non-CDD staff attorneys.
8.7. Comp. time in all divisions for mandatory after-hours work.
8.8. Reasonable exceptions to private practice ban during leaves of absence.
9. Part-Time Work.
9.1. Annual step increases.
9.2. Fully-paid health benefits.
9.3. Consistent policy across divisions.
9.4. Increase number of slots.
10. Expense Allowances.
10.1. Increase arraignment cab fare, and extend to other assignments.
10.2. Meal allowance for other off-hour assignments.
10.3. Paid local bar association dues.
10.4. Foreign language training and/or class reimbursement.
11. Quality of Representation.
11.1. Standardize CDD felony certification.
11.2. Attorney:support staff ratios.
11.3. Stronger workload protection.
11.4. Union input on responses to oversight committee reports.
M E M O
To: Executive Board
Fr: Michael Letwin
Re: Activation of Bargaining Subcommittees
Da: May 9, 2001
Listed below are the bargaining subcommittees established by last night’s EB. Each convener (**) should hold meetings between her subcommittee and Theresa, et al (preceded by ALAA caucuses) to explore areas of agreement; the subcommittees will be asked to report the results of these meetings at the June 12 EB.
Compensation/Expenses (Prop. #1-2, 10)
Albro**
Bing-Hampson
Byrne/Popper
Hughes
Mulligan
Zuss
Benefits/Insurance (Prop. #3-7)
Albro
Blum
Holder
Smith**
Torres
Work Schedules (Prop. #8-9)
Bahr
Codling**
Part-Timers
Popper
Quality of Representation (Prop. #11)
Geida
Hochberg
Korotzer
Letwin**
Mulligan
Narra
Zuss
Minutes of Special ALAA Delegate Council: April 30, 2001
Legend: Black=Present; Gray=Absent; Lowercase=Alternate; Parens=Other ALAA Members
Executive Board
President: LETWIN
Secretary-Treasurer: ALBRO
Recording Secretary: HITCHCOCK
VP–CAB/CAP/Fed: BLUM, P. (Acting), A1: Vacant
VP–CDD/Bx: GELTMAN, A1: Vacant
VP–CDD/Bk: ZUSS, A1: *Torres, A2: *Korotzer
VP–CDD/M: GEIDA, A1: Mulligan
VP–CDD/Qns: POPPER, *A1: Byrne
VP–Civil: HOLDER; A1: Vacant
VP–JRD: HOCHBERG, A1: Vacant
VP–Vol. (CLO): BING-HAMPSON, A1: Rosa-Rios, A2: Vega, A3: Edwards
ACLA: *CODLING
Aff. Action: VACANT
Health & Safety: *KOROTZER
Health: *SMITH
Junior: *HUGHES
Lesbian & Gay: *BAHR
Senior: *TORRES
*Nonvoting in this capacity
Criminal Appeals Bureau (CAB)
COHEN, FABIANO, GRAVES, HARPAZ, HOPKIRK, LANDAU, LITTLE, PETERS, A1: Taglieri, A2: Blum, P, A3: Sender
Capital Defender Division
VACANT
Criminal Defense Division (CDD)-Bronx
BxA: ROGERS, SIM, A1: Rush-Fox, A2: Montoya, A3: Roman
BxB: GARCIA, GURWITCH, A1: Meyerson, A2: Peppito, A3: Warshowksy
BxC: ABBANDANDO, BOMBA, A1: Rudin, A2: Beltre, A3: Kelly
BxD: FOLLETT, IPPOLITO, A1: Sturman, A2: Albo, A3: Follett
Criminal Defense Division (CDD)-Brooklyn
BK1: BAKER, BELL, A1: Costigan, A2: Newton, A3: Dinjian
BK2: ANGRISANI, ASHWORTH, A1: Korotzer, A2: Pitts, A3: Wright
BK3: RITTER, SHEEHAN, A1: Alzugaray, A2: Flanders, A3: Morris
BK4: PELLEGRINO, CASHMAN, A1: Kurtz, A2: Rudnick, A3: Rahall
BK5: DAVILA, PRATT, A1: Newman, A2: Wasserman, R.
Criminal Defense Division (CDD)-Manhattan
M1: DALEY, NEVINS, (Anderson, Wool)
M2: GROSS, NARRA
M3: BAHR, SCHWARZ, A1: Michaeu
M4: MARON, MULLIGAN, A1: Shapiro
M5: ROBERTS, SOTO
M6: AFFLER, WRIGHT, A1: Zablocki
Spec Lit: WASSERMAN
Criminal Defense Division (CDD)-Queens
Q1: GRUNDSTEIN, MORRISON, A1: Linneman, A2: Vacant
Q3: FREDERICK, KNIGHTLY, A1: Haase, A2: Savage, A3: LoPiccolo
Q4: AUSTIN, DIFLUMERI, A1: Byrne, A1: Auguste, A3: Horowitz
Civil Division
Aging: BOEHM, A1: Hosannah, A2: Bart, A3: Durham
Appeals/HRP: GOLDFEIN, KELLEHER, A1: Goldiner, A2: Bock
Bronx: FRIEDER, STOLLER, A1: Goetz
Brooklyn Neighborhood Office (BNO): PIZZIMENTI, ROSENBERG
Far Rockaway: SHORTELL, A1: Dierking, A2: Fielding
Harlem: SACKEY, A1: Shaeffer, A2: Barbosa
Immigration: FLOYD-MAYER, A1: Navarro
Lower Manhattan Neiborhood Office (LMNO): RHULEN, A1: Bodden
Queens: FLORES, A1: Mombrun, A2: Kim, A3: Friedheim
Staten Island: MARCUS, A1: Sanchez, A2: McCann
(Davol)
Federal Defender Division
Appeals & SDNY: STATSINGER
EDNY: PADDEN, Solotaroff
Juvenile Rights Division (JRD)
Appeals/Spec Lit: EGGER, A1: Rosenbloom
Bronx: ROMAN, A1: Abbey, A2: Nevergold
Brooklyn: KARASYK, A1: Koslow, A2: Baum, A3: Nolan
Manhattan: LAMB, MARTIN, A1: Pappadopoulos
Queens: BOWLER, SCREEN, A1: Mittler, A2: Chiu
Staten Island: LEE
Parole Revocation (PRDU)
LOPEZ
Prisoners Rights Project
ZELERMYER, A1: Beritan
Volunteer Division/(Community Law Office)
MARIS, CODLING, A1: Epstein, *A2: Edwards
NB: Italics=Adopted motion
1. Introduction. Letwin explained the purpose of this special meeting to address CDD/CAB staffing/workload in light of ongoing budget crisis.
2. Background & Context. Letwin and Albro reviewed the following.
2.1. City budget & LAS Council testimony.
2.2. Litigation.
2.3. Mayoral elections.
3. Response.
3.1. Central Report. Letwin reported that ALAA representatives from CDD and CAB met with divisional and central management on April 3 to express need for plan to reduce CDD intake, and on Executive Board discussion about how to survive coming year through (1) Boro-specific plans to reduce intake to acceptable work levels; (2) Management shoulder fair burden (e.g., vacation schedules, DATs, etc.); (3) End petty harassment by management.
3.2. Local Reports. In discussion of each CDD boro, representatives reported that Manhattan and Brooklyn are in particularly acute workload crisis. Blum reported that CAB faces challenge of reversing dramatic reduction of case assignment by the appellate divisions.
3.3. MOTION: Affirm ALAA’s support for immediate implementation of the following steps necessary to weather the current budget/staffing crisis in CDD and CAB: (1) Boro-specific measures that reduce CDD workload to levels at which attorneys can provide ethical, high-quality legal representation in each case; (2) Assumption of fair workload burden by CDD supervisors (e.g., priority for staff attorney vacation requests, handling of additional work assignments, etc.); (3) Supportive and respectful treatment of staff attorneys by managers in the course of daily interaction; (4) Prompt, aggressive, proactive responses by CDD management to abuse of staff attorneys by judges, DAs, and/or other court personnel (e.g., violation of 1 a.m. end to night arraignments, contempt/disciplinary threats, etc.); (5) Fostering of mutual support amongst, rather than competitive comparison between, staff attorneys in various criminal offices and/or divisions. The above position will be pursued at both office and citywide levels. (Passed: Unanimously.)